Global Policy Forum

MP Says Iraq Holds Thousands in Secret Prisons


By Simon Bradley

October 31, 2008

Thousands of Iraqis are being detained illegally in 420 secret government-controlled places of detention, an Iraqi parliamentarian claims. Sunni opposition MP Mohammad Al-Dainy is in Geneva to meet United Nations and Red Cross officials to request help to investigate "massive human rights violations" in Iraq. "These centres of detention are completely illegal. No one can visit them. The conditions are much worse than in the official prisons," Al-Dainy told journalists in Geneva on Thursday. The MP said that since 2006 he had gained access to 13 such prisons, three of which were jointly controlled by the US and the Iraqi government, to document human rights abuses. He added that he had obtained government reports that proved the existence of a secret network of locations. His investigations and video footage were used as part of a hard-hitting documentary film, "Iraq: The Death Squads" by director Deborah Davies, which won the prestigious British Royal Television Society Award for International Current Affairs in 2007.

Al-Dainy believes 26,000 people are currently detained in Iraq by US forces. On top of this, 40,000 people are being held in 37 official government-controlled prisons, but the MP believes this is only "one quarter of the total number being held" in Iraq. "In one secret prison I visited, hundreds of prisoners were crammed into each of the six rooms," he recounted. "There are all kinds of people, men, women and children – in one prison there was 23 minors." In Al-Dainy's disturbing video footage, several detainees recount their torture at the hands of police commandos: nails ripped out, burns, beatings and rape. "They forced us to talk by raping us," said one man, who claimed to be an imam. "The reason he confessed was to save his family who were brought before him. He was told to choose between either confessing to murder or seeing his family raped. Despite the fact he confessed, he himself was raped twice," said Al-Dainy.


Yassin Hiyat, an Iraqi governmental representative in Geneva responsible for human rights, told swissinfo that this was "the first time" he had heard about secret government-controlled prisons. According to a United Nations report, some 51,000 people were detained by US forces and the Iraqi government at the end of last year. The report said some abuse had reportedly taken place during initial interrogations when detainees were held at pre-trial detention facilities, including police stations. In its 2008 annual report, Amnesty International said reports of torture and other ill-treatment of detainees - including minors - by Iraqi security forces, particularly Interior Ministry forces, were common. It said as in previous years, the government had announced investigations into specific allegations of abuse by Iraqi security forces, but failed to make public the outcome, adding to concerns that impunity was widespread. "We raised the issue a couple of years ago that we were concerned that security forces under the Ministry of Interior may be responsible for abuses," said Amnesty spokeswoman Nicole Choueiry, adding that it was extremely difficult to confirm Al-Dainy's charges of secret places of detention.

The Swiss-run ICRC presently visits some 19,000 detainees held by US forces and has requested access to government-controlled places of detention in Iraq, but a global visit accord has still not been finalised. ICRC spokeswoman Dorothea Krimitsas said she was unable to confirm or deny Al-Dainy's allegations of secret places of detention. "We do not know. We only have access to three places of detention under the control of the Iraqi authorities," she said. "We receive allegations from people who are arrested and whose whereabouts is unknown," she declared. "For security reasons we cannot access all places of detention."

Investigation failure

Al-Dainy complained that the normal process for investigating rights' abuses "was not working", as officials wanting to visit places of detention were not being granted permission. "The United Nations Assistance Mission for Iraq (UNAMI) has a human rights representative in Iraq but their role is weak and they are nonexistent," he added. The MP wants the international community to intervene and is calling for the re-appointment of the UN Human Rights Council Special Rapporteur for Iraq to investigate human rights violations. This week he met representatives of the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) and a number of human rights non-governmental organisations. Al-Dainy is also urging the creation of an ad hoc international tribunal to investigate human rights abuses – both past and present. "The judicial system is ineffective," he added. The MP said he was risking his life travelling to Geneva to reveal these facts. Eleven members of his family had been killed in 2006 due to the work he carried out uncovering the secret prison, Dyalah. "I'm an MP and this puts me in danger. I'm going back to Baghdad and it will not stop us. It makes us go forward to discover more," he said. "I am here as a parliamentarian who wants the suffering in Iraq to end and to ensure that the Iraqi people can live in safety."

More Information on Iraq
More Information on International Law Aspects of the Iraq War and Occupation
More Information on Torture and Prison Abuse in Iraq


FAIR USE NOTICE: This page contains copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Global Policy Forum distributes this material without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. We believe this constitutes a fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in 17 U.S.C § 107. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond fair use, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.